She Was in the Wrong Place, at the Wrong Time Alexandra “Ally” Zapp slain at a Bridgewater Mass. rest area

Alexandra “Ally” Zapp slain at a Bridgewater Mass. rest area

Alexandra “Ally” Zapp was murdered on July 18, 2002 Zapp was on her way home to Newport, Rhode Island from a charity event in Boston when she stopped at the rest area on Massachusetts Route 24 in Bridgewater around midnight.Burger King employee and repeat sex offender Paul Leahy, 40, watched and waited as Zapp entered the women’s bathroom. According to police reports and a later confession by the killer, when Zapp opened the door to leave the restroom, Leahy stood in the doorway with a knife in his right hand and shoved her back inside. Zapp pleaded with Leahy, and then fought for her life as he proceeded to stab her in the chest a total of six times.Zapp also sustained defensive knife wounds to her arm, wrist, hand, and chin.

In the nearby men’s room, off-duty state police lieutenant Stephen O’Reilly heard Zapp’s muffled screaming. As he approached the women’s room door, he saw red puddles. With his gun drawn, he stepped inside to find Leahy standing next to the sink covered in blood.

Trial

Leahy was charged with first-degree murder, kidnapping, armed robbery, and armed assault with intent to rob.Prosecutor Frank Middleton said the evidence was overwhelming, thanks mostly to the testimony of Lt. Stephen O’Reilly, the trooper who caught Leahy in the act of cleaning up after the murder.

Also key to the prosecution’s case was a statement Leahy made to police, in which he confessed that he intentionally stabbed the young woman. After initially conceding that he had only stabbed Zapp twice in the arm, he admitted to stabbing her in the chest when he was confronted with autopsy results.

Leahy’s criminal history dates back to 1981, with a history of sexual offenses beginning in 1984. Some of his victims were as young as 13 years old. With a mountain of evidence facing his client, defense lawyer Frank Spillane did not make a case to get his client acquitted of all charges, but instead concentrated his efforts on proving Zapp’s death was not an intentional act of murder.

Spillane argued that his client’s actions were in response to the circumstances confronting him. He said that his client did not plan, plot or lie in wait for Alexandra Zapp.

When Leahy was waiting for Zapp to come out of the restroom, Spillane said, he was deciding whether or not to rob her. Spillane said his client did not intend to hurt Zapp, and that the battle in the bathroom erupted spontaneously. He alleged the defendant was simply reacting to a situation that had spiraled out of control.

On September 24, 2003, Paul Leahy was found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to life without parole.