?⚖️ Duxbury Mother Seeks Two-Phase Trial in Triple Homicide Case
Duxbury, MA — In a closely watched legal proceeding this month, 35-year-old Lindsay Clancy, the Duxbury mother charged with murdering her three young children in January 2023, appeared in court and formally asked a Plymouth County Superior Court judge to divide her upcoming murder trial into two distinct phases.
Clancy’s defense team has proposed that the trial begin with a “guilt phase” where a jury would first determine whether prosecutors can prove beyond a reasonable doubt that she committed the killings. A second phase would then focus solely on her mental state at the time of the alleged crimes, particularly the question of whether she suffered from a severe mental disease or defect — a legal consideration closely related to an insanity defense.
The motion to bifurcate the trial reflects strategic legal planning by Clancy’s attorneys, who argue that separating factual guilt from mental health issues will allow jurors to better assess complex psychiatric evidence without conflating it with decisions about criminal responsibility.
Clancy, who has pleaded not guilty to three counts of murder, was present in the courtroom for the motion hearing — her first in person — after previously appearing virtually from Tewksbury State Hospital, where she has been held under supervision since the alleged incident. Authorities say she strangled her children — 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson, and 8-month-old Callan — at their family home, then attempted suicide by jumping from a second-floor window, an act that left her paralyzed.
Defense attorney Kevin Reddington has indicated that Clancy’s mental state — including severe postpartum depression or possible psychosis — will be central to her legal strategy, and that narrowing the legal questions into phases may ensure jurors consider the evidence on each issue more clearly.
The next scheduled court dates include additional hearings on procedural motions and a psychiatric evaluation of Clancy, with the full trial currently expected to begin in July 2026.
This motion marks a notable step in the ongoing legal process of one of Massachusetts’s most tragic and controversial criminal cases in recent years, and it underscores questions about mental health, legal responsibility, and trial procedure as the case moves forward.
Dear Pilgrim
Have a local perspective to share? Send us your thoughts for the Pilgrim Letters.
Write to Us
Clancy’s defense team has suggested that the trial commence with a “guilt phase,” during which a jury would assess whether the prosecution can establish beyond a reasonable doubt that she is responsible for the murders. Given the evidence already available, it seems clear that she is guilty of triple homicide, making this case appear straightforward. While there may be discussions about her mental state, I have little doubt about her unstable condition.
She’s definitely unstable, and I sincerely hope she remains behind bars.