Plymouth Faces Dispute With Native American Group Over Thanksgiving Day of Mourning Agreement
PLYMOUTH, MASS— A dispute between the Town of Plymouth and a Native American-led advocacy organization is escalating ahead of Thanksgiving, with the group accusing town officials of violating a decades-old agreement governing its annual demonstration.

The United American Indians of New England (UAINE) is seeking court intervention over the town’s handling of the annual National Day of Mourning, an Indigenous gathering that has taken place in Plymouth on Thanksgiving since 1970.
According to Boston.com, UAINE alleges that Plymouth voted on November 10 to breach a 1998 settlement agreement that established protections for the organization’s annual rally and march.
The group filed an emergency motion seeking a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction against the town.
The disagreement centers on several issues, including the availability of a stage, insurance requirements and proposed changes to the location and route of the demonstration.
The 1998 agreement followed a confrontation between police and demonstrators during the 1997 National Day of Mourning. More than 100 police officers surrounded demonstrators, 25 people were arrested and several individuals were injured, according to published reports.
The following year, the organization dropped a civil rights lawsuit in exchange for the town dropping charges against demonstrators and agreeing to allow the annual event without additional permitting requirements.
The agreement also included provisions for the town to provide a stage for the gathering.
Town officials have offered a different perspective on the current dispute. According to the Plymouth Independent, the town says it has been working with organizers and maintains that insurance and liability protections should be required.
Select Board Chair Deb Iaquinto said the town supports the National Day of Mourning and has offered organizers alternative accommodations, including the use of Pilgrim Memorial Park.
The dispute follows a similar legal battle last year, when a judge prohibited the town from requiring insurance, compensation or permits for the demonstration and ordered the town to provide a stage at Cole’s Hill under the agreement.
UAINE maintains that the latest requirements violate the terms of the settlement and limit the organization’s ability to hold its annual demonstration.
The 57th annual National Day of Mourning is scheduled for Thursday, November 26, at noon in Plymouth. Organizers say the event will proceed as planned.
The legal dispute remains ongoing, with the organization asking the court to intervene before Thanksgiving.
Sources: Boston.com and Plymouth Independent.
Donate to Plimoth Today
Help sustain Plimoth & local Plymouth County news. Empower community journalism today!
