The Brutal 1984 Murder of Virginia Hannon in Pembroke MA Solved

The Brutal 1984 Murder of Virginia Hannon in Her Pembroke MA Home

PEMBROKE, MA – Nearly four decades have passed since the brutal murder of Virginia Hannon, a 59-year-old Pembroke resident, in her own home. Found stabbed and strangled in 1984, her slaying remains one of the South Shore’s most enduring and tragic cold cases, leaving family and the community searching for answers.

On an unspecified date in 1984, Hannon’s life was violently cut short when she was discovered deceased inside her Pembroke residence. Law enforcement officials at the time confirmed she had been both stabbed and strangled, indicating a struggle and a deeply personal or frenzied attack.

The horrific discovery launched a massive investigation by the Pembroke Police Department and Massachusetts State Police detectives assigned to the Plymouth County District Attorney’s Office. Despite extensive efforts – including interviews, forensic analysis, and public appeals – no arrests were ever made in connection with Hannon’s death. The case eventually went cold, leaving family and friends without answers for decades.

For many in the close-knit community of Pembroke, the memory of Virginia Hannon’s unsolved murder continues to cast a long shadow. While active leads may have dwindled over the years, law enforcement typically emphasizes that cold cases are never truly closed. Advances in forensic technology, particularly DNA analysis and new investigative techniques, often offer renewed hope for such cases.

Authorities periodically revisit cold cases like Hannon’s, hoping for fresh information or a break that could lead to an arrest. The passage of time can also sometimes encourage individuals who may have withheld information to come forward. For the family of Virginia Hannon, the desire for justice and closure remains as strong now as it was 39 years ago.

UPDATE :

In 2019, investigators found that DNA samples taken from Ms. Hannon’s house — including broken glass from the door, bloody paper towels and the nylon stockings that had been used to strangle her — were all linked to the same unknown man.

But attempts to identify that man through forensic genealogy, which uses genetic evidence to identify the relatives of criminals and eventually the criminals themselves, were not successful, investigators said.

Then the tipster called the police, one day after Mr. Aylward died in February 2020. Mr. Cruz said the person, whom he declined to describe, said Mr. Aylward had made a confession in early 2019.

“He said he killed somebody in Pembroke many years ago,” Mr. Cruz said. “There’s really not a lot of information I can tell you about it other than the fact that, obviously, this tipster knew this individual, and they had conversations, and they made those statements.”

He said it was fortunate that the call had come so soon after Mr. Aylward died, because the authorities were able to retrieve DNA samples from Mr. Aylward’s body at the hospital. Detectives also searched a home in Brockton, about 12 miles west of Pembroke, where Mr. Aylward was believed to have lived.

Mr. Aylward’s DNA matched the DNA samples that had been taken from the crime scene, including the broken glass on the door, the bloody paper towels and the nylon stockings, Mr. Cruz said.

“We have exhausted all of the evidence that we currently have,” Mr. Cruz said, “and it all points in the direction of Jesse Aylward.”

Still, he said, the evidence did not solve the mystery of why Ms. Hannon had been killed. “You know, the DNA gets us to the people, but it doesn’t necessarily get us to what exactly happened,” he said.

Mr. Hannon thanked the police for never having given up on his aunt’s case, saying that “a little closure for her is nice.” But he said he hoped that someone who knew Mr. Aylward would call the authorities to explain who he was and why he might have killed Ms. Hannon.

“Somebody will remember, I believe,” he said. “Somebody will be brave enough to come forward.”

On February 13, 1984, 59-year-old Virginia Hannon was found strangled and stabbed in her home in Pembroke, Massachusetts. For 37 years, law enforcement and the Hannon family have sought justice for her unsolved murder. On March 4th of 2021, the Plymouth County District Attorney’s office announced that they had identified Virginia Hannon’s killer as Jesse Aylward. Over the years, the police conducted extensive investigations, interviews, DNA testing, and forensic genealogy testing. Unfortunately, previous attempts at identifying the killer using DNA technology failed. However, in 2020, a tip from a man led to State police detectives obtaining a warrant to obtain blood from Aylward, which matched the DNA found on the crime scene evidence. Retired Pembroke Police Chief Wall spoke at the announcement about the ongoing work on this case since 1985.